« Treasure Law in Great Britain | Main | Solar Caution - not scepticism, but go-slowism »
July 21, 2007
Finding Harry Potter Annoying (don't worry, I don't know how it turns out)
I agree with Megan - plenty of J.K. Rowling's world doesn't make any sense - and in the bad way. Here's an example:
Yet in the Potter books, the costs and limits are too often arbitrary.I'd never thought about the last one - students are often hurt by misfires at Hogwarts, but no one ever seems tired at the end of class.
A patronus charm, for example, is awfully difficult - until Rowling wants a stirring scene in which Harry pulls together an intrepid band of students to Fight the Power, whereupon it becomes simple enough to be taught by an inexperienced fifteen year old. Rowling can only do this because it's thoroughly unclear how magic power is acquired. It seems hard to credit academic labour, when spells are one or two words; and anyway, if that were the determinant, Hermione Granger would be a better wizard than Harry. But if it's something akin to athletic skill, why is it taught at rows of desks? And why aren't students worn out after practicing spells?
I won't be reading it until come across a neglected copy of my nephews. I'm a volume behind, anyway.
Posted by CrankyProfessor at July 21, 2007 7:36 AM