Poor Amanda Knox, the American student accused and convicted of murdering her British roommate while they were both studying in Italy. My general opinion of the Italian justice system is not very high — and in this case it is even lower.
The whole system is highly politicized and incredibly prosecutor-driven, and like the usual Continental system, there is no assumption of innocence until proven guilty. Knox was certainly tried and found guilty in the Italian press. I have very little confidence this appeal will free her.
The strangest thing I’ve read about the case is the epilogue to a true-crime book, The Monster of Florence, by Douglas Preston and Mario Spezi.
Il Mostro di Firenze is the Son of Sam of Italy — a serial killer who, between 1968 and 1985, stalked lovers’ lanes around Florence and shot smoochers in the head. Preston got interested in the case when he moved to Florence to write a novel set in the Renaissance; he met Spezi, an Italian journalist who had covered the Mostro case from the beginning. As they re-interviewed old contacts of Spezi and began pushing further suddenly Spezi came under investigation by the Mostro prosecutor (if I could find my copy I’d find his name!) and Spezi is jailed for obstruction of justice and perhaps being an original accomplice of il Mostro (Italian society and judicial procedures are rife with conspiracy theory). Preston leaves Italy on the advice of friends that he is next on the arrest list.
In the epilogue to the 2008 The Monster of Florence, Preston explains that the prosecutor who lit into Spezi and was on his trail was from Perugia — where he was prosecuting Amanda Knox.
This particular prosecutor seems (according to Preston) to suffer from the conspiracy theory subspecies “it’s Satanists!” He was always finding Satanic connections for il Mostro, and he started off his prosecution of Knox with dope and Satanism. Honest.
So, I’m not too sanguine.
Oh – I found Preston’s short version of the whole book in an Atlantic article — you have to get to page 5 to find the prosecutor, Giuliano Mignini. It’s well-worth reading if you’re interested in Italian justice.
further:
Looks like she’s acquitted. I hope it sticks!